The Russian economy is eating its own muscle to survive as Putin’s war on Ukraine destroys future capacity, former central bank advisor says
Four years after Vladimir Putin ordered an invasion of Ukraine, Russia’s economy has entered a “death zone,” said Alexandra Prokopenko, a fellow at the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center.
In a recent Economist op-ed, the former Russian central bank advisor drew on a term from mountain-climbing, when high altitude forces the body to consume itself faster than it can repair itself.
“Russia’s economy is stuck in what might be described as negative equilibrium: holding itself together while steadily destroying its own future capacity,” she wrote.
The economy isn’t headed for an imminent crash, but GDP has stagnated, oil revenue has been halved amid Western sanctions, and the government’s budget deficit is rapidly draining reserves.
At the same time, two economic systems have emerged. One comprises the military and related industries that receive priority from the Kremlin. And then there’s everything else that’s been “left in the cold,” Prokopenko explained.
“The most dangerous feature of this new structure is the fuel it burns,” she added. “Russia’s economy now runs on what might be called ‘military rent’: budget transfers to defense enterprises that generate wages and economic activity.”
But the transfers are aimed at assets designed for destruction, Prokopenko pointed out. In other words, the money that keeps Russia’s factories humming pays for tanks, armored vehicles, and other weapons that eventually get destroyed or damaged, making them useless for future economic growth.
Similarly, money spent to attract fresh recruits to Russia’s army doesn’t retrain them to become more productive. Instead, many die or return home permanently wounded. The Center for Strategic and International Studies has estimated Russian military casualties at 1.2 million, including 325,000 killed.
“The body is metabolizing its own muscle tissue for energy,” Prokopenko said.
While the central bank has cut interest rates to prop up growth, and the Kremlin has taken steps to rein in the budget deficit, Russia’s economic predicament can’t be fixed with monetary or fiscal policies, she wrote.
In fact, interest payments on government debt this year are already set to exceed spending on education and health care combined.
Unlike a cyclical downturn such as a recession, Prokopenko argued that what Russia is suffering from is more akin to altitude sickness—“the longer you stay, the worse it gets, regardless of rest.”
But Putin can’t afford to climb back down the mountain as the economy has becoming increasingly reliant on the defense sector, while a military demobilization would likely trigger an economic crisis. And rather than end the war, Putin insists on continuing as he waits to see if Ukraine or its Western backers crack first.
First Appeared on
Source link